First Down

Cheat Sheet · 2026 · Week 9

Week 9
cheat sheet.

The start ’em and sit ’em picks, sleepers and busts of week 9 of the 2026 NFL season, PPR scoring, with what each player actually scored.

Open the interactive Cheat Sheet

Week 9 was played before the Cheat Sheet existed: these picks were rebuilt afterwards from Sleeper’s projections for that week, without the injury news of the time, so they don’t count in the track record.

Every player expected to play is ranked at his position twice: by this week’s score (Sleeper’s projection, his recent form and the matchup) and by his usual points per game. The players whose week stands out from their usual level are the picks. Half-PPR, standard, kickers, defenses and every IDP pick are in the interactive Cheat Sheet; how the picks work.

Offense

Start ’em 1 of 10 hit

Usually just outside the starters, a starter this week.

  1. Colston Loveland TE · CHI vs TB — TE7 this week, usually TE18. Easy matchup: the TB defense allows +5% to TEs. Projection 11.1, recent form 13.1, season average 9.2. Miss: 9.4 points, TE15.
  2. Ladd McConkey WR · LAC vs HOU — WR24 this week, usually WR42. Easy matchup: the HOU defense allows +30% to WRs. Projection 13.1, recent form 7.8, season average 8.6. Miss: did not play.
  3. Patrick Mahomes QB · KC vs NYJ — QB7 this week, usually QB15. Projection 21.0, recent form 15.6, season average 18.5. Hit: 16.5 points, QB12.
  4. Kyle Pitts Sr. TE · ATL vs CIN — TE12 this week, usually TE20. Easy matchup: the CIN defense allows +17% to TEs. Projection 9.8, recent form 12.3, season average 8.2. Miss: 5.3 points, TE31.
  5. Devin Singletary RB · NYG vs PHI — RB18 this week, usually RB33. Projection 14.2, recent form 12.3, season average 8.4. Miss: 5.9 points, RB40.
  6. Rashee Rice WR · KC vs NYJ — WR15 this week, usually WR27. Tough matchup: the NYJ defense allows −11% to WRs. Projection 15.6, recent form 13.1, season average 11.3. Miss: 9.9 points, WR37.
  7. Matthew Stafford QB · LAR vs WAS — QB11 this week, usually QB16. Easy matchup: the WAS defense allows +19% to QBs. Projection 18.7, recent form 16.7, season average 17.5. Miss: 12.2 points, QB20.
  8. Ollie Gordon II RB · MIA vs DET — RB17 this week, usually RB27. Tough matchup: the DET defense allows −18% to RBs. Projection 14.9, recent form 14.3, season average 10.3. Miss: 7.4 points, RB33.
  9. Woody Marks RB · HOU vs LAC — RB22 this week, usually RB30. Easy matchup: the LAC defense allows +8% to RBs. Projection 13.8, recent form 9.8, season average 8.9. Miss: 8.4 points, RB27.
  10. Saquon Barkley RB · PHI vs NYG — RB24 this week, usually RB32. Tough matchup: the NYG defense allows −10% to RBs. Projection 12.6, recent form 11.0, season average 8.4. Miss: 8.2 points, RB28.

Sit ’em 7 of 10 hit

Usually a starter, outside the starters this week.

  1. Dalton Kincaid TE · BUF vs MIN — TE19 this week, usually TE8. Tough matchup: the MIN defense allows −50% to TEs. Projection 9.6, recent form 7.7, season average 11.3. Hit: 5.8 points, TE29.
  2. Devaughn Vele WR · NO vs CLE — WR42 this week, usually WR22. Tough matchup: the CLE defense allows −7% to WRs. Projection 8.6, recent form 10.9, season average 12.3. Hit: 3.7 points, WR77.
  3. Tyler Shough QB · NO vs CLE — QB19 this week, usually QB12. Tough matchup: the CLE defense allows −18% to QBs. Projection 16.0, recent form 16.9, season average 18.8. Miss: 19.7 points, QB8.
  4. Derrick Henry RB · BAL vs JAX — RB26 this week, usually RB12. Tough matchup: the JAX defense allows −24% to RBs. Projection 11.9, recent form 12.4, season average 17.1. Hit: 5.6 points, RB43.
  5. Breece Hall RB · NYJ vs KC — RB29 this week, usually RB16. Tough matchup: the KC defense allows −9% to RBs. Projection 10.7, recent form 10.7, season average 14.2. Miss: 11.7 points, RB16.
  6. Adonai Mitchell WR · NYJ vs KC — WR33 this week, usually WR24. Tough matchup: the KC defense allows −22% to WRs. Projection 10.3, recent form 11.6, season average 12.1. Hit: 0.0 points, WR128.
  7. Jordan Love QB · GB vs NE — QB14 this week, usually QB10. Tough matchup: the NE defense allows −10% to QBs. Projection 17.1, recent form 20.2, season average 19.4. Miss: 36.2 points, QB2.
  8. Braelon Allen RB · NYJ vs KC — RB25 this week, usually RB18. Tough matchup: the KC defense allows −9% to RBs. Projection 10.3, recent form 16.5, season average 12.5. Hit: 5.4 points, RB46.
  9. Tre Tucker WR · LV vs SF — WR28 this week, usually WR21. Tough matchup: the SF defense allows −9% to WRs. Projection 11.0, recent form 12.8, season average 12.5. Hit: 9.5 points, WR40.
  10. Aaron Jones Sr. RB · MIN vs BUF — RB27 this week, usually RB21. Easy matchup: the BUF defense allows +23% to RBs. Projection 9.9, recent form 11.9, season average 11.4. Hit: 3.1 points, RB55.

Busts 6 of 7 hit

Still a starter, but well below his usual output.

  1. Isaiah Likely TE · NYG vs PHI — Expected 11.7 points, 27% below his 16.1 average. Tough matchup: the PHI defense allows −32% to TEs. Projection 11.1, recent form 15.3, season average 16.1. Miss: 16.3 points, TE4.
  2. Josh Jacobs RB · GB vs NE — Expected 15.4 points, 22% below his 19.7 average. Tough matchup: the NE defense allows −15% to RBs. Projection 15.0, recent form 17.7, season average 19.7. Hit: 0.5 points, RB67.
  3. Josh Allen QB · BUF vs MIN — Expected 21.7 points, 21% below his 27.5 average. Tough matchup: the MIN defense allows −49% to QBs. Projection 22.5, recent form 23.3, season average 27.5. Hit: 13.9 points, QB16.
  4. Ashton Jeanty RB · LV vs SF — Expected 13.4 points, 19% below his 16.5 average. Projection 12.3, recent form 15.4, season average 16.5. Hit: 7.0 points, RB34.
  5. Trey McBride TE · ARI vs SEA — Expected 15.4 points, 18% below his 18.8 average. Tough matchup: the SEA defense allows −27% to TEs. Projection 15.4, recent form 18.3, season average 18.8. Hit: 12.4 points, TE6.
  6. James Cook III RB · BUF vs MIN — Expected 15.8 points, 16% below his 18.8 average. Tough matchup: the MIN defense allows −17% to RBs. Projection 15.2, recent form 20.2, season average 18.8. Hit: 16.7 points, RB8.
  7. Chris Olave WR · NO vs CLE — Expected 15.0 points, 16% below his 17.8 average. Tough matchup: the CLE defense allows −7% to WRs. Projection 15.5, recent form 14.8, season average 17.8. Hit: 16.8 points, WR12.

IDP

Start ’em 2 of 5 hit

Usually just outside the starters, a starter this week.

  1. Nick Emmanwori DB · SEA vs ARI — DB2 this week, usually DB37. Easy matchup: the ARI offense allows +16% to DBs. Projection 12.6, recent form 15.4, season average 11.9. Miss: 7.0 points, DB103.
  2. Tykee Smith DB · TB vs CHI — DB11 this week, usually DB39. Easy matchup: the CHI offense allows +14% to DBs. Projection 12.7, recent form 12.0, season average 11.6. Hit: 22.0 points, DB8.
  3. Xavier McKinney DB · GB vs NE — DB17 this week, usually DB41. Tough matchup: the NE offense allows −10% to DBs. Projection 12.2, recent form 12.4, season average 11.5. Hit: 24.0 points, DB6.
  4. Devon Witherspoon DB · SEA vs ARI — DB16 this week, usually DB34. Easy matchup: the ARI offense allows +16% to DBs. Projection 11.2, recent form 13.0, season average 12.0. Miss: 14.0 points, DB41.
  5. Kendal Daniels LB · ATL vs CIN — LB11 this week, usually LB28. Easy matchup: the CIN offense allows +8% to LBs. Projection 13.4, recent form 19.8, season average 14.9. Miss: 14.0 points, LB41.

Sit ’em 4 of 5 hit

Usually a starter, outside the starters this week.

  1. C.J. Henderson DB · ATL vs CIN — DB78 this week, usually DB15. Easy matchup: the CIN offense allows +7% to DBs. Projection 6.6, recent form 13.1, season average 14.6. Hit: 6.0 points, DB128.
  2. Malcolm Roach DL · DEN vs CAR — DL54 this week, usually DL17. Easy matchup: the CAR offense allows +23% to DLs. Projection 4.3, recent form 11.2, season average 11.8. Hit: 5.0 points, DL102.
  3. Jevón Holland DB · NYG vs PHI — DB48 this week, usually DB11. Projection 9.8, recent form 11.4, season average 15.2. Hit: 10.0 points, DB71.
  4. Byron Murphy Jr. DB · MIN vs BUF — DB52 this week, usually DB17. Projection 9.6, recent form 11.2, season average 13.9. Hit: 16.0 points, DB27.
  5. David Bailey LB · NYJ vs KC — LB31 this week, usually LB9. Tough matchup: the KC offense allows −23% to LBs. Projection 11.4, recent form 17.9, season average 17.7. Miss: 41.0 points, LB3.

Sleepers 1 of 5 hit

Usually deep on the bench, flex-worthy this week.

  1. Caleb Downs DB · DAL vs IND — DB9 this week, usually DB50. Easy matchup: the IND offense allows +14% to DBs. Projection 14.2, recent form 9.2, season average 11.1. Hit: 26.0 points, DB4.
  2. Laiatu Latu DL · IND vs DAL — DL24 this week, usually DL61. Tough matchup: the DAL offense allows −9% to DLs. Projection 10.5, recent form 6.8, season average 7.0. Miss: 13.0 points, DL48.
  3. Ji'Ayir Brown DB · SF vs LV — DB34 this week, usually DB70. Easy matchup: the LV offense allows +6% to DBs. Projection 11.2, recent form 9.4, season average 10.1. Miss: 3.0 points, DB166.
  4. Abdul Carter DL · NYG vs PHI — DL32 this week, usually DL60. Projection 9.3, recent form 6.6, season average 7.1. Miss: 1.0 points, DL225.
  5. Montez Sweat DL · CHI vs TB — DL36 this week, usually DL59. Projection 8.5, recent form 6.8, season average 7.2. Miss: 14.0 points, DL38.

Busts 4 of 5 hit

Still a starter, but well below his usual output.

  1. Kyler Gordon DB · CHI vs TB — Expected 11.7 points, 46% below his 21.7 average. Easy matchup: the TB offense allows +7% to DBs. Projection 9.2, recent form 16.7, season average 21.7. Hit: 6.0 points, DB131.
  2. Alex Singleton LB · DEN vs CAR — Expected 15.8 points, 31% below his 23.0 average. Tough matchup: the CAR offense allows −12% to LBs. Projection 12.6, recent form 26.4, season average 23.0. Hit: 8.0 points, LB77.
  3. Greg Rousseau DL · BUF vs MIN — Expected 15.4 points, 30% below his 22.1 average. Easy matchup: the MIN offense allows +9% to DLs. Projection 13.7, recent form 17.6, season average 22.1. Hit: 19.0 points, DL21.
  4. Blake Cashman LB · MIN vs BUF — Expected 16.7 points, 30% below his 24.0 average. Projection 13.0, recent form 24.8, season average 24.0. Miss: 26.0 points, LB12.
  5. Devin Lloyd LB · CAR vs DEN — Expected 14.6 points, 30% below his 20.8 average. Tough matchup: the DEN offense allows −30% to LBs. Projection 15.9, recent form 13.0, season average 20.8. Hit: 16.0 points, LB38.

← Week 8All 2026 weeksWeek 11 →